American Airlines flights from New York to Key West

Recent searches for flights from New York to Key West

Aug 2026
From$457*
Updated: 1 hour ago
Round tripIEconomy
Sep 2026
From$330*
Updated: 11 hours ago
Round tripIEconomy
Oct 2026
From$339*
Updated: 10 hours ago
Round tripIEconomy
cmp-daily-histogram-bars-legend-min-price-aria-label $339
cmp-daily-histogram-bars-legend-max-price-aria-label $764
Displaying fares for August-2026
  • JFK–EYW, 08/27/26 – 09/03/26: From $509
    27

    Th

    AUG

  • JFK–EYW, 08/28/26 – 09/04/26: From $509
    28

    Fr

  • JFK–EYW, 08/29/26 – 09/05/26: From $457
    29

    Sa

  • JFK–EYW, 08/30/26 – 09/06/26: From $509
    30

    Su

  • LGA–EYW, 08/31/26 – 09/07/26: From $764
    31

    Mo

  • NYC–EYW, 09/01/26 – 09/08/26: From $467
    01

    Tu

    SEP

  • JFK–EYW, 09/02/26 – 11/19/26: From $398
    02

    We

  • NYC–EYW, 09/03/26 – 09/10/26: From $435
    03

    Th

  • NYC–EYW, 09/04/26 – 09/11/26: From $435
    04

    Fr

  • NYC–EYW, 09/05/26 – 09/12/26: From $381
    05

    Sa

  • NYC–EYW, 09/06/26 – 09/13/26: From $561
    06

    Su

  • NYC–EYW, 09/07/26 – 09/14/26: From $435
    07

    Mo

  • NYC–EYW, 09/08/26 – 09/15/26: From $414
    08

    Tu

  • NYC–EYW, 09/09/26 – 09/16/26: From $356
    09

    We

  • NYC–EYW, 09/10/26 – 09/17/26: From $356
    10

    Th

  • NYC–EYW, 09/11/26 – 09/18/26: From $356
    11

    Fr

  • NYC–EYW, 09/12/26 – 09/19/26: From $365
    12

    Sa

  • NYC–EYW, 09/13/26 – 09/20/26: From $471
    13

    Su

  • NYC–EYW, 09/14/26 – 09/21/26: From $364
    14

    Mo

  • NYC–EYW, 09/15/26 – 09/22/26: From $364
    15

    Tu

  • JFK–EYW, 09/16/26 – 09/23/26: From $339
    16

    We

  • NYC–EYW, 09/17/26 – 09/24/26: From $420
    17

    Th

  • NYC–EYW, 09/18/26 – 09/25/26: From $418
    18

    Fr

  • NYC–EYW, 09/19/26 – 09/26/26: From $356
    19

    Sa

  • JFK–EYW, 09/20/26 – 09/27/26: From $486
    20

    Su

  • JFK–EYW, 09/21/26 – 09/28/26: From $339
    21

    Mo

  • JFK–EYW, 09/22/26 – 09/29/26: From $339
    22

    Tu

  • NYC–EYW: cmp-view-offers-disclaimer. Find Offers
    23

    We

  • NYC–EYW: cmp-view-offers-disclaimer. Find Offers
    24

    Th

  • JFK–EYW, 09/25/26 – 09/28/26: From $390
    25

    Fr

  • JFK–EYW, 09/26/26 – 10/03/26: From $339
    26

    Sa

    • range$339-$764

    DisclaimerFares displayed have been collected within the last 24hrs and may no longer be available at time of booking. Modifying this information may result in a different fare. To find the most updated fare, please visit aa.com. Fares listed may be Basic Economy, which class is subject to additional terms and conditions. Additional baggage fees and charges for optional products and services may apply.

    Find deals on New York to Key West flights

    $
    keyboard_arrow_down

    New York (NYC)to

    Key West (EYW)
    09/30/26 - 10/07/26

    Round trip

    Economy

    from
    $330Fare subject to changes
    Updated: 11 hours ago

    New York (NYC)to

    Key West (EYW)
    11/17/26 - 11/24/26

    Round trip

    Economy

    from
    $335Fare subject to changes
    Updated: 1 hour ago

    New York (NYC)to

    Key West (EYW)
    11/19/26 - 11/26/26

    Round trip

    Economy

    from
    $335Fare subject to changes
    Updated: 1 hour ago

    New York (NYC)to

    Key West (EYW)
    11/04/26 - 11/11/26

    Round trip

    Economy

    from
    $335Fare subject to changes
    Updated: 1 hour ago

    New York (NYC)to

    Key West (EYW)
    11/10/26 - 11/17/26

    Round trip

    Economy

    from
    $335Fare subject to changes
    Updated: 1 hour ago

    New York (NYC)to

    Key West (EYW)
    11/16/26 - 11/23/26

    Round trip

    Economy

    from
    $335Fare subject to changes
    Updated: 1 hour ago

    New York (NYC)to

    Key West (EYW)
    11/18/26 - 11/25/26

    Round trip

    Economy

    from
    $335Fare subject to changes
    Updated: 1 hour ago

    New York (NYC)to

    Key West (EYW)
    10/10/26 - 10/17/26

    Round trip

    Economy

    from
    $339Fare subject to changes
    Updated: 1 hour ago

    *Fares displayed have been collected within the last 24hrs and may no longer be available at time of booking. Some fares listed may include one or more connections that are Basic Economy, which class is subject to additional terms and conditions. Modifying this information may result in a different fare. To find the most updated fare, please visit aa.com. Additional baggage fees and charges for optional products and services may apply.

    Finding cheap flights from New York to Key West

    Looking for lower fares on your trip from New York to Key West? Here are a few ways to save.

    • Book early: Booking 1 to 3 months ahead can help you find lower fares
    • Be flexible with dates: Midweek travel, like Tuesdays and Wednesdays, can be more affordable
    • Travel during less busy periods: Flying outside peak travel times can help find lower fares and avoid crowds

    Earn up to $500 back on your next American Airlines flight plus, 30,000 bonus miles. Offers vary elsewhere. Opens another site in a new window that may not meet accessibility guidelines.

    Upgrade your flight with Main Cabin Extra

    Make your trip more comfortable with Main Cabin Extra. Enjoy benefits like:

    • Extra legroom: More space with seats at the front of the Main Cabin or in exit rows.
    • Early boarding: Preferred Group 5 boarding allows easier access to overhead bins.
    • Complimentary drinks: Enjoy beer, wine and spirits on flights with full beverage service.

    Discover how Main Cabin Extra can enhance your trip.

    American Airlines flights from New York to Key West